Leave a Message
Thank you for your message. I will be in touch with you shortly.
Explore Our Properties
Airy cream living room with a linen sofa, oak furnishings, and a window overlooking a small terrace and late-autumn trees.

Downsizing Without Leaving Yorktown, and When the New Options Arrive

On Catherine Street in Yorktown, the Field Home was built in stages between 1887 and 1924 and spent its working life caring for older women. It now sits at the edge of the town's newest plan for older residents. In November 2025 the Yorktown Planning Board approved Toll Brothers' 118-home subdivision there. As part of the plan, Toll will donate the Field Home and the 3.05 acres around it, and about 14.3 acres will go under a conservation easement, according to the Town of Yorktown's announcement. In that same announcement, Supervisor Ed Lachterman described the homes as a way for older Yorktown residents to downsize from single-family houses without leaving town.

For a Yorktown owner who wants that kind of move, the new homes change the math and the calendar. The new 55+ townhomes are expected to start above what the middle Yorktown house sold for in October. The other new project is rental, and its construction is expected to finish well after a house listed this winter would close. For a Yorktown owner, the decision is less about how much smaller to go and more about the order of moves.

The Two New Addresses, and What Each One Is

The Catherine Street project is now marketed as Regency at Hunterbrook. On Toll Brothers' community page it appears as a "Coming Soon" 55+ townhome community, priced from the $1,000,000s, with two or three bedrooms, one or two stories, and 1,184 to 2,970 square feet. The approved plan includes a clubhouse and a pool.

The second project is a different kind of housing. Sylvan Woods Yorktown, by AMS Acquisitions, is going up at 800 East Main Street in Jefferson Valley, where the Blue Book Network's offices used to be. Westfair Communications reported in February 2026 that construction had begun on 180 rental apartments for residents 55 and up: 74 one-bedrooms and 106 two-bedrooms. More than 70% of the site, about 26 acres, will stay open space. The planned amenities include a pool, a fitness center, a spa with steam and sauna rooms, sports courts and walking trails. AMS already runs a 148-unit Sylvan Woods community for residents 55 and up in the Village of Buchanan.

So one project sells townhomes and the other rents apartments. They suit different households, and the gap between them matters most for timing and price.

Where the New Townhomes Start, Compared With What Yorktown Houses Sold For

In October 2026, the median sale price of a single-family home in Yorktown was $757,000, about 1% lower than in October 2025. The average sale price that month was $797,382. Regency at Hunterbrook is expected to start in the $1,000,000s.

Put those two figures together. An owner who sells a typical Yorktown house and buys one of the new townhomes would probably add money to the move rather than take some out. For some households that is the right trade. A newly built home with one-floor living, a clubhouse and no exterior work can be worth more than the extra square footage they give up. It is still a different decision from the one people usually mean by downsizing. It works best when the reason for the move is a different way of living and freeing up cash is not the main goal.

Yorktown also sits below the county median. OneKey MLS put the Westchester County single-family median at $1,189,000 for the third quarter of 2026, up 10.0% from a year earlier. A new townhome priced from the $1,000,000s fits the county's price range much more easily than it fits Yorktown's.

The Calendar Is the Harder Constraint

Westfair reported in February that AMS expected to finish construction in "the second half of next year," which means the second half of 2027. At an October 5, 2026 Planning Board meeting, an AMS representative proposed putting a double-wide leasing trailer inside the gated site to handle preleasing. The board recommended that the Town Board approve it with standard conditions, according to a Citizen Portal summary of the meeting. Rents for the 180-unit plan have not been published.

Regency at Hunterbrook is still listed as coming soon, with no published sales date.

That leaves a gap. A Yorktown house listed this winter could close by spring 2027, months before Sylvan Woods' construction is expected to wrap up and before Hunterbrook has a published sales date. Anyone who wants to move into one of them has three options. They can sell early and rent somewhere in between. They can sign up early and carry the house longer. Or they can buy into Yorktown's existing 55+ housing now.

The rental option also changes what happens to the owner's money. Moving to Sylvan Woods turns home equity into a sum of money and a monthly rent. The household keeps the proceeds and decides separately how to hold them. A purchase, whether at Hunterbrook or anywhere else, keeps the money in property.

Yorktown Already Has Older 55+ Housing

Yorktown already has a large stock of 55+ housing, which is easy to forget while the new projects get attention. Jefferson Village in Yorktown Heights is a 55+ condominium community of 1,000 units, built between 1967 and 1982, within walking distance of the Jefferson Valley Mall. A Westchester County fact sheet notes Bee-Line Route 16 service at the mall nearby. Trump Park Residences at 100 Trump Park in Shrub Oak has 141 one-, two- and three-bedroom 55+ condominiums. Glassbury Court, next door to the Hunterbrook site on Catherine Street, has 64 homes, The Examiner News reported.

These communities have the one thing the new projects can't offer yet: homes you can move into now. They also sell in a different part of the market from the house the owner is leaving. Across Westchester County in the third quarter of 2026, the condominium median sale price was $615,000. Condo inventory was up 11.1% from a year earlier, while single-family inventory was down 6.6%. Condos had 3.0 months of supply, compared with 2.5 months for single-family homes. Single-family sellers received 106.2% of their original list price on average, and condo sellers received 101.0%.

Those are county figures, not Yorktown's. Still, they point the same way for a downsizer. Their house is in the tighter market, and the home they'd buy is in the market with more choices and less bidding. That combination favors the seller who is also buying. The house is the asset most likely to bring a strong price, and the condo is the purchase most likely to leave some room to negotiate.

What the House Is Doing This Fall

Yorktown's single-family market is still firm, but it has room in it this fall. In October 2026, 34 single-family homes were for sale at month's end, 54.5% more than in October 2025. Months of inventory rose to 2.00. Average days on market went to 45, up 45.2% from both September and October 2025. Sales held steady at 17, and the homes that sold went for 102.12% of list price.

So buyers had more homes to choose from and took longer to decide, and they still paid above list for the homes they chose. With only 17 sales in a month, a few closings can move the median, so the more useful number is the third quarter. The Yonkers Times summary of Houlihan Lawrence's Q3 2026 report shows the northwest Westchester group, which includes Yorktown, with sales up 3% and the median price up 7% from the third quarter of 2025.

For an owner thinking about the move, rising inventory changes how the house should be listed more than whether to list it. With 34 houses competing instead of 22, the house that is priced correctly and ready to show on its first weekend is the one that gets the 102% result. A house that waits for spring will face its own competition. The Westchester County numbers already show listings building in the condo segment.

Choosing the Order of Moves

Both projects will change two familiar Yorktown sites. The Field Home will have a new purpose, and Jefferson Valley will gain 180 new homes on a hilltop where the Westfair piece places it, where the Taconic State Parkway meets Route 6. After the Town Board's 4–1 vote in May 2025, Lachterman said in a May 19 town press release that the 800 East Main project would give residents downsizing from single-family homes a way to stay in Yorktown, Yorktown News reported.

For a household deciding this winter, the question is which move comes first. Waiting for Hunterbrook means carrying the house until there is a sales date, and probably adding money at closing. Waiting for Sylvan Woods means a sale, a temporary home and a rent that can start only once construction finishes, which AMS expects in the second half of 2027. Moving now probably means a home in Jefferson Village, Trump Park or another existing community, bought in a market with more inventory, using money from a house that still sells above list.

Any of these can be the right answer. The best choice depends on whether the household cares most about cash, a new building or less waiting.

If you're working out the order of your own move within Yorktown, from timing a sale against a 2027 construction schedule to pricing your house for this winter's buyers, Isabel R. Alves can help. Start with a home valuation built on this season's numbers, or look through her seller resources. Let's Connect.

REAL ESTATE INSIGHTS

Follow Us On Instagram